Why September is the Best Time to Visit Cape Cod!

September is one of the best times to visit Cape Cod, as the crowds have thinned out with kids back in school, but the weather remains mild and inviting. In this blog, we’ll explore the best events, hikes, towns, beaches, and dining experiences that make September a hidden gem for Cape Cod enthusiasts. Plus, I’ll highlight why the Old Manse Inn is the perfect place to book your September getaway.

Events in September

Cape Cod hosts several vibrant events in September that showcase the region’s rich culture and charm.

  1. Harwich Cranberry Arts & Music Festival (September 14-15): Celebrate the cranberry harvest with live music, local artisans, and delicious food. Harwich is the heart of cranberry country, and this festival gives you a taste of Cape Cod’s history and flavor.
  2. Truro Treasures Weekend (September 20-22): This beloved local event features a mix of activities including a flea market, antique car show, and even a grape stomp. Truro’s scenic beauty and tight-knit community come alive during this fun-filled weekend.
  3. Wellfleet OysterFest (October 19-20): This prelude to the main event in October is still worth checking out if you’re a seafood lover. Enjoy fresh oysters, craft beer, and entertainment in a quintessential Cape Cod town.

Top Hiking Trails for September

With cooler temperatures and fewer bugs, September is ideal for exploring Cape Cod’s diverse hiking trails. Here are a few hikes where you can soak in the natural beauty of the region:

  1. Great Island Trail, Wellfleet: This 8-mile trail is one of the Cape’s most scenic hikes, offering a mix of forest, marsh, and stunning ocean views. In September, the warm hues of early fall add a new layer of beauty to this already spectacular trail.
  2. Fort Hill Trail, Eastham: With sweeping views of Nauset Marsh and the Atlantic Ocean, this easy 1.5-mile trail is a great choice for those seeking a shorter hike. September’s cooler temperatures make the climb to the top of Fort Hill a breeze.
  3. Nickerson State Park, Brewster: If you want a mix of shaded woodlands and serene ponds, this 1,900-acre park is perfect for a fall hike. Trails vary in length and difficulty, allowing everyone from beginners to seasoned hikers to enjoy a relaxing walk in nature.

Towns to Explore in September

September is the ideal time to visit some of Cape Cod’s most charming towns. Without the summer crowds, you can explore these quaint villages at your leisure.

  1. Chatham: Known for its picturesque Main Street and historic lighthouse, Chatham is a quintessential Cape Cod town. September is the perfect time to browse the unique shops, enjoy an outdoor lunch, or take a boat tour from the marina.
  2. Provincetown: This vibrant, artsy town at the tip of the Cape offers everything from eclectic galleries to beautiful beaches. In September, you can enjoy the town’s lively atmosphere without battling peak-season crowds. Don’t miss a sunset at Race Point Beach while you’re there!
  3. Brewster: This charming town is home to the Old Manse Inn and offers the perfect mix of historic charm and natural beauty. From antique shops to pristine beaches, Brewster in September is all about relaxation and exploration.

Best Beaches for a September Visit

While summer may be over, September still offers plenty of warm days perfect for beach outings. Here are a few must-visit beaches:

  1. Skaket Beach, Orleans: Known for its stunning sunsets and gentle waves, Skaket Beach is a top choice for evening strolls and sunset watching in September. The tide pools also make it a fun stop for families.
  2. Coast Guard Beach, Eastham: Often ranked among the top beaches in the country, Coast Guard Beach is a great place to take in the beauty of Cape Cod’s coastline. The wide, sandy beach and dramatic dunes create the perfect backdrop for a September beach day.
  3. Breakwater Beach, Brewster: A favorite among locals, this beach offers calm waters and a long stretch of sand at low tide. It’s the perfect spot for families and anyone looking to enjoy a quieter beach experience. You can also walk from the Old Manse Inn to this beautiful beach and experience the “Brewster Flats” during low tide so make sure to include this during your vacation.

Top Restaurants for Dinner in Brewster

Cape Cod is known for its fresh seafood and farm-to-table dining, and Brewster has some hidden gems that are perfect for a memorable dinner.

  1. Brewster Fish House: This upscale seafood spot is a must-visit if you’re craving the freshest catches. The menu changes seasonally, ensuring that you’ll enjoy the best flavors Cape Cod has to offer.
  2. Spinnaker: Located in the heart of Brewster, Spinnaker offers a cozy, upscale dining experience with dishes inspired by Mediterranean and New England cuisine. The intimate atmosphere makes it a great choice for a romantic evening.
  3. Stone L’Oven Pizza Co.: For a more casual dining option, this spot serves up wood-fired pizzas with locally sourced ingredients. It’s a great place for families or groups looking for a relaxed night out.
  4. Island Blue Crab: This restaurant offers a relaxed atmosphere and serves up a variety of great entries on the Cape. With a menu featuring fresh catches and creative twists on classic dishes, Island Blue Crab is perfect for those looking to enjoy a delicious dinner during their September stay.

Don’t forget to also check out our latest Blog: 5 Must-Try Spots for Great Cape Cod Lobster Rolls: A Foodie’s Guide

Best Beaches for September Sunsets

Cape Cod is famous for its sunsets, and September offers some of the most spectacular views of the year. Here are a few must-visit spots for a sunset experience:

  1. First Encounter Beach, Eastham: The combination of wide tidal flats and the golden glow of the setting sun creates a magical experience here. It’s a peaceful spot to end your day on Cape Cod.
  2. Rock Harbor, Orleans: This beach is known for its striking sunsets, with boats docked in the harbor silhouetted against the sky. It’s a perfect place to take in the beauty of the Cape at dusk.
  3. Paine’s Creek Beach, Brewster: This smaller beach is a local favorite for sunset viewing. The tidal creek and salt marshes create a stunning foreground as the sun dips below the horizon.

Don’t forget to check out our latest blog: Discover Paradise: The Top 15 Beaches and Tranquil Trails of Cape Cod!

Why Book Your September Stay at the Old Manse Inn?

The Old Manse Inn is the perfect base for your September getaway to Cape Cod. Nestled in the heart of Brewster, our historic inn offers a blend of classic New England charm and modern comforts. Each of our rooms is uniquely decorated, offering a cozy retreat after a day of exploring the Cape.

 

Book Now

 

What makes the Old Manse Inn special? Here’s what sets us apart:

  1. Prime Location: Our central location in Brewster puts you within easy reach of some of the best beaches, hiking trails, and towns on the Cape.
  2. Personalized Experience: From gourmet breakfasts to curated itineraries, we ensure every guest enjoys a tailored experience that suits their needs and interests.
  3. Charming Accommodations: Our award-winning rooms are designed with both comfort and style in mind. Whether you stay in one of our Medal Mania-winning rooms like the Bass River Light or Chatham Light, you’re sure to enjoy a peaceful and relaxing stay.
  4. Exclusive Amenities: Enjoy complimentary parking, wifi, beach chairs, and more during your stay. We also offer wine and cheese hours Wednesdays – Sundays, perfect for unwinding after a day of adventure.

Also check out our latest itinerary for a four day stay in Cape Cod to gather some ideas from our latest blog: Exploring Cape Cod: A 4-Day Adventure!

Conclusion

September is a magical time to experience the best of Cape Cod. Whether you’re attending local festivals, hiking scenic trails, or enjoying a sunset by the beach, there’s something for everyone. Don’t forget to make the Old Manse Inn your home away from home for the perfect blend of comfort and Cape Cod charm.

Reservations
Posting the 2027 Calendar this Labor Day - Monday, September 7, 2026 - Click Here for More Details

We are Looking Forward to Our 14th Season in 2027!

Updated August 7, 2026

Dear Old Manse Inn Family,

Charlie and Brian hope that this note finds you all doing well.  We have been having our best time hosting you all ever since opening our doors way back in 2013!

What a season 2026 has been so far too!  We had our best May and July ever and have been thrilled that you have enjoyed all of the updates & renovations we introduced at the beginning of the season.  We look forward to showing you even more updates with both new guests and our beloved return guests alike.  Our photo albums per room showcase all of the updates to the Old Manse that we have been so happy to make over the last 13 years.  The scrumptious new recipes for breakfast, especially the Orange Croissant Egg Bake and Lemon Ricotta Pancakes went over really well.  Sign up for our newsletter to receive all of the updates!

As we start to prepare for the new 2027 season, our calendar will be posted on Labor Day – Monday, September 7th.  So if you are seeking specific dates and/or specific guest rooms, book early.  You will receive the best rates as well before the calendar starts to fill up!

Don’t forget that since becoming members of Select Registry (SR) in 2023, we now have 2 reward programs going strong into 2025.  Our original program is based on the number of stays here at the Inn.  We recently had to expand our program to 20 stays as returning guests have already reached 15 stays with us!  The SR program is based on the number of nights.  Every 12 nights you stay, you get $100 that can be used at any Select Registry inn across the country!  Please contact us for more information.

In the meantime, if you have any questions about booking a reservation or want more details about your stay, please reach out directly to us at the Inn via email ([email protected] or phone 508-896-3149).

We look forward to welcoming you all for a great stay!

All Our Best,

Brian & Charlie